An analysis of IMF pandemic support to Egypt, Nigeria,
president has stated that “[c]ountries will need to
Ecuador, and Cameroon found that while the IMF
implement structural reforms” for the recovery and that
secured transparency commitments that spurred all
“[f]or those countries that have excessive regulations,
four governments to publish information about their
subsidies, licensing regimes, trade protection or
spending and contracts, the amount, accessibility, and
litigiousness as obstacles, we will work with them to
quality of the disclosed information varied widely and
foster markets, choice and faster growth prospects
in none of the countries was it adequate for meaningful
during the recovery.”36
oversight. In Nigeria, for instance, the government has
34
so far failed to disclose beneficial ownership information
In the Philippines, the national health system has
for companies receiving government funds for COVID-19
suffered decades of neglect, compounded by corruption
response, and has not adequately published data on how
and neoliberal policies favoring the privatization
COVID-19 funds have been spent.
and commercialization of public services. The ADB’s
35
pandemic response overlooked this reality and instead
used the same neoliberal logic to diagnose the challenges
IFIs’ neoliberal prescriptions made
countries more vulnerable to the
pandemic, yet the institutions
continue to push policy reforms
and conditionalities that harm
those living in poverty or otherwise
marginalized.
facing the health system as simply a lack of finance.
Researchers point out that without a governance system,
the influx of ADB financing didn’t deliver promised
results. Instead, they cite massive corruption around
government procurement of medical supplies,
unexplained losses of the Philippine Health Insurance
Corporation, health care workers who were not paid their
risk allowance, and inadequate government hospitals.37
In Mozambique, the country has a long history of
Many developing and middle income countries went
IFI-imposed austerity. Today, World Bank investment
into the pandemic already in a state of vulnerability born
is equivalent to the national budget. Researchers
out of neoliberal prescriptions and debt obligations that
describe how the World Bank’s attempt to outsource
hollowed out the public sector, privatized basic services,
social protection payment systems to private financial
eliminated social protection programs, flexibilized
service providers can be seen as an expropriation of
labor markets and enabled corporate capture. IFIs
state functions, coupled with the privatization of state
have neither taken responsibility for these actions and
assets. They also describe how the Bank attempted to
the resulting poverty and inequality, nor have they
use the pandemic to fast-track the collateralization
changed course. Today IFIs vigorously promote the
of land, a move that would be devastating for women
“private sector first” paradigm, focusing on leveraging
and other poor or marginalized farmers. As the
private investment rather than supporting countries in
researchers conclude, the COVID-19 pandemic has
rebuilding state capacity.
created an opportunity for the World Bank to fast-track
financialization under the guise of transparency,
The World Bank and other IFIs have utilized the
efficiency, and effectiveness38
pandemic and their outsized influence on cash-strapped
nations to secure the adoption of policy reforms and
austerity measures that actually harm women, the
poor, and other marginalized groups. The World Bank
34 “IMF: Scant Transparency for Covid-19 Emergency Loans: AntiCorruption Measures a Step Forward, but Weak Implementation”,
Human Rights Watch, March 30, 2021,
https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/03/30/imf-scant-transparencyCOVID-19-emergency-loans.
35 “Between Hunger and the Virus: The Impact of the Covid-19
Pandemic on People Living in Poverty in Lagos, Nigeria”, Human
Rights Watch and Justice & Empowerment Initiatives - Nigeria, 2021,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/07/28/between-hunger-and-virus/
impact-COVID-19-pandemic-people-living-poverty-lagos#_ftn269.
36 Remarks by World Bank Group President David Malpass
on G20 Finance Ministers Conference Call on COVID-19, March
23, 2020, available at https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/
speech/2020/03/23/remarks-by-world-bank-group-president-davidmalpass-on-g20-finance-ministers-conference-call-on-COVID-19.
37 Freedom from Debt Coalition, December 2021.Philippine antiCOVID19 fight: Where is the caring for the people?”, Freedom from
Debt Coalition, December 2021.
38 Edgar Barroso, Ruth Castel-Branco and Bonaventura Monjane,
“Fast-tracking Financialization: International Financial Institutions’
Responses to the Covid-19 Pandemic,” (ALTERNACTIVA - Acção Pela
Emancipação Social), November 2021.
WHERE DID INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS’ COVID-19 FUNDING GO?
10