03
spend about 15 days a month, travelling
areas. However, this solution failed,
large distances to reach far-flung areas.
increased the burden on the state and
However, because the INAS is understaffed,
undermined its distributional regime1.
payments are highly irregular. Furthermore,
manual payments pose security risks for
INAS staff and beneficiaries – and leave
staffers with little time for other important
duties such as the provision of social
services. All evaluations point to the need
to improve the payment system. However,
how to do so remains a challenge.
In response to the Covid-19 pandemic,
the World Bank set up a Working Group
on Payment Systems which overlapped
with the Working Group on Adaptive
Social Protection. Vodacom was selected
to administer the PASD-PE payments.
To facilitate electronic transfers, most
beneficiaries were offered a cell phone
With the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic,
and Mpesa accounts. However, Vodacom
the World Bank teamed up with tech
struggled to implement a digitalised
billionaires to launch the G2Px initiative,
payment system. In the midst of long delays
a new ‘payment ecosystem’, where
and growing political unrest, INAS brought
customers choose between a range of
the payment system back in-house. For
private providers. Ignoring accepted views
now, most beneficiaries will continue to be
that outsourcing was costly, G2Px insisted
paid manually using INAS’ Offline Payment
that digitalization and outsourcing of cash
App, while the World Food Programme
transfers would ensure savings in the long-
pilots e-wallet payments among 94,000
run (Gelb & Mukherjee, 2020).
urban households (MGCAS/ILO, 2021). The
The World Bank had already tried to
outsource cash transfers in Mozambique.
However, limited digital literacy and limited
connectivity made electronic payments
unworkable, and poor infrastructure made
manual payments unprofitable. Because
of this financial service providers were
reluctant to bid for tenders.
World Bank blames the failed outsourcing
process on a restrictive regulatory
environment for financial services. However,
the government points to a number of other
challenges, including the limited number of
service providers with the network coverage
and necessary infrastructure to respond to
the needs of the programme at a national
scale; the lack of experience working with
The World Bank then proposed a model
people with limited (digital) literacy; and
based on electronic payments in urban
lengthy delays in the disbursement of funds
centres and manual payments in rural
by the World Bank2.
1 Interview with a former tender coordinator by Ruth Castel-Branco, 12 October 2021, Maputo.
2 Interview with a state representative by Ruth Castel-Branco in Maputo, 13 October 2021.
18
Fast-tracking Financialization - International Financial Institutions’ Responses
to the Covid-19 Pandemic in Mozambique