THE CONTESTED INFLUENCE OF IFI’S OVER LABOUR AND SOCIAL PROTECTION POLICY
The final challenge was the lack of INAS
even further. While Vodacom assumed
support and the absence of an effective
responsibility for making payments via
complaints’ mechanism. According to the
Mpesa – which it ultimately struggled to
survey, a quarter of respondents declared
do – it was not responsible for the myriad
that they had to pay a “success fee” to
of other interactions which usually take
gatekeepers to be registered in the PASD-
place between INAS representatives and
PE. While most beneficiaries knew that
beneficiaries. Yet with resources diverted
there was a complaints mechanism in
to private providers there were not enough
place, nearly half had no idea of where to
resources to strengthen INAS’ response on
go to lodge a complaint or register a stolen
the ground.
phone (PMSC-PS, 2020). The government
tried to establish a hotline staffed by
the World Food Program (WFP) but as a
representative of SINED says, it was not
effectively implemented: “All people could
do was wait. There was no hotline where
they could consult timelines or lodge
complaints.” Historically, INAS has relied on
thousands of quasi-volunteers at the local
level called “permanentes” to disseminate
information, identify potential beneficiaries
and troubleshoot problems. In exchange
for their work, “permanentes” receive
a subsidy equivalent to a cash transfer.
Although insignificant, it incentivizes
collaboration by compensating volunteers
for their time. However, under the guise
of transparency, “permanentes” were
Social Security always saw the PASD-PE
as a peripheral programme. The primary
objective of social protection has been
to respond to the structural causes of
vulnerability along the life cycle rather
than idiosyncratic shocks. Nevertheless,
the intensification of shocks – droughts,
floods, Covid-19 – have transformed social
protection into highly targeted, short-term,
shock responsiveness programmes. Under
the guise of Adaptive Social Protection,
debates about the redistributive role of
the state are simply deflected onto the
household and the private sector through
elusive ideas like livelihood diversification
and financial inclusion.
excluded from the PASD-PE, even as their
The challenge facing the Mozambican
workload increased exponentially, leading
government is how to reconcile these
to a contraction in the quality of support
conflicting visions. As one official succinctly
provided to recipients.
put it: “We can be pretty sure that after six
Ultimately, the outsourcing of the payment
process fragmented the relationship
between INAS and cash transfer recipients
21
Notably, the National Strategy for Basic
months, PASD-PE beneficiaries will fall back
into poverty, and we will lose the gains
made. We have to keep working to increase
the fiscal space and expand coverage. We
Fast-tracking Financialization - International Financial Institutions’ Responses
to the Covid-19 Pandemic in Mozambique