Snapshot review of Two World Bank COVID-19 Health support programs in Egypt
Through the contextual study, we observe that the World Bank has historically had two
approaches to their projects in Egypt, following two different development strands. While the
World Bank states in their Country Partnership Framework (CPF) that long term development
through institutional capacity building is their approach, this is only observed through the GRM
workshops carried out in 2016. The workshops are a good example of long-term institutional
building, which is a more effective development strategy as it is a better prescriptive approach to
systemic inefficiencies. However, as observed in the “Transforming Egypt’s Healthcare System”
project, much of the progress was targeted towards the fulfillment of objectives, instead of long
term eradication. This translated into relatively successful national campaigns, that are not aimed
at a long term institutional remedy. This approach is reflected in the procurement plans of the
project, which are mostly garnered towards the purchase of drugs which are a one-time perishable
instead of medical equipment and supplies that will serve as a long term investment. Certainly,
the purchase of medical drugs in fighting viruses is of high importance, but the sole focus on their
procurement offsets the balance of health reform. Additionally, with the expected shift of funding
to be directed towards the emergent vaccines, it is plausible that COVID-19 response measures
will take a backseat. This approach would be prescriptive to symptoms, especially since a variety
of measures adopted to counter COVID-19 were generally good capacity building measures for
the health sector, especially with increased training of health workers. Therefore, while the
emergence of the vaccine certainly sheds light unto a new direction, neglecting measures
previously mandated COVID-19 measures would be a missed opportunity in the direction of
healthcare reform, especially in consideration of Egypt’s ambitious universal health care law. The
World Bank’s projects in the health sector present a real opportunity aiding Egypt in steering this
new direction, Egypt has promising foundational structures, despite some systemic inefficiencies.
Recommendations:
The study recommends that the World Bank reconfigures a system of checks and balances that
ensures that the cycle of information sharing is an ongoing process at all levels of the project.
That the different components and on-ground activities of the projects are visible to
stakeholders/civil society so that they can work on better project-related issues and ensure the
wellbeing of involved communities. Moreover, a further recommendation is the revision of the
SEP, as well as the GRM system adopted at the project level. It is encouraged that regular
assessments are made about the real effectiveness of the GRMs in place. Lastly, periodic reports
disclosed on the World Bank portal, though important, need to include actual information about
where program activities are beyond implemented and how accountability and community
monitoring can be carried out.
21
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos